The All-American Rejects are the pop punk equivalent of a boy band, by which I mean their fan base is almost exclusively 12 year old girls. This being the case, why do I like them so much? 12 year old girls are almost always wrong about everything, and we don't usually have overlapping tastes. This is probably one of the cases where it's best to not think about it too much.
Move Along is the album that made the band famous, partially because they became a TRL staple with the videos from this album. While TRL is generally the place where bad music is rewarded by idiots, I actually really like this album. It isn't quite as good as the band's debut, but the songwriting is strong enough to make this a nice guilty pleasure.
Baleeted? Nope, but you don't have to tell everyone I said so.